Stupid Roofer Tricks: How to Avoid Getting Scammed While Protecting Your Biggest Investment
When the hail finally stops, an uneasy quiet settles over the neighborhood. Homeowners step outside to assess the damage, stress already creeping in, when a truck pulls up, and a friendly contractor is suddenly at the door offering “storm-special pricing.” In Oklahoma, this scenario plays out after almost every major hail event.
The financial stakes are significant. The average cost of a new roof in Oklahoma (particularly in areas like Oklahoma City) now ranges from about $8,000 to $30,000 or more, with many typical residential projects falling between $9,000 and $18,000 for asphalt shingles on average-sized homes (around 1,800–2,500 sq ft of roof area). Broader estimates, including larger or more complex roofs, or storm-resistant upgrades, can push totals up to $40,000 depending on size, material (e.g., impact-resistant asphalt, metal), pitch, and complexity.
Combine that with Oklahoma’s consistently high exposure to hail damage—where the state ranks among the top in the U.S. for hail events (averaging around 297 per year) and experiences annual insured/property losses often in the $80+ million range, with older per-capita estimates around $21–$30 (and recent analyses placing it in the higher tier alongside states like Colorado and Nebraska)—and it becomes clear why storms continue to attract both reputable professionals and bad actors looking for quick money.
This guide is not generic roofing advice. At Parker Brothers Roofing, we see the same deceptive tactics repeated after every storm. Even savvy homeowners can fall for them when stress is high. Your roof is one of the largest investments in your home, and making the wrong decision under pressure can create long-term financial consequences.
Why A Roofer’s Offer to Pay Your Deductible Is a Red Flag
One of the most common post-storm pitches is the promise to “cover your deductible.” This tactic is frequently used by storm-chasing contractors trying to secure contracts as quickly as possible. While it can sound appealing, it often signals high-pressure sales tactics or an attempt to lock homeowners into work they may not need.
In many cases, contractors who offer this incentive plan recover the cost through inflated pricing, reduced material quality, or shortcuts in workmanship. Before agreeing to anything, homeowners should speak directly with their insurance provider and consult a trusted local roofer who can provide an honest assessment without pressure.
The Danger of Contractors Without a Local Presence
After major hailstorms, Oklahoma neighborhoods often see an influx of out-of-state roofing crews. These storm chasers follow severe weather from region to region, capitalizing on widespread damage and quick contracts.
Common warning signs include trucks with out-of-state plates, no verifiable local office to visit, and aggressive sales tactics, such as urging homeowners to sign immediately so work can start the next day. Once payment is collected, many of these contractors disappear, leaving homeowners with voided warranties, unresolved issues, and no local support if problems arise.
This is not a hypothetical risk. Oklahoma has seen contractors face felony charges for exactly this kind of post-storm fraud. Working with a local company like Parker Brothers Roofing means accountability, long-term service, and a team that will still be here years after the storm has passed.
Why Manufacturer Certifications Matter
In an industry where claims and promises are easy to make, elite manufacturer certifications are one of the clearest indicators of professionalism and quality. While many roofers advertise themselves as “certified,” the highest designations are rare and difficult to earn.
Two of the most respected roofing credentials are GAF Master Elite® and Owens Corning Preferred Platinum. GAF Master Elite® status is held by roughly two percent of roofing contractors nationwide and requires proper licensing, full insurance coverage, and a proven track record of high-quality workmanship. Owens Corning Preferred Platinum represents another top tier, reserved for contractors who consistently meet the manufacturer’s highest standards.
Contractors who hold both certifications operate at an elite level. These credentials provide homeowners with stronger warranty options, higher installation standards, and confidence that the work will be done correctly the first time. Parker Brothers Roofing is one of just two roofing contractors in Oklahoma that hold both certifications.
How Scammers Exploit Post-Storm Anxiety
Oklahoma homeowners are conditioned to act quickly after storms, and unethical contractors know this. They use fear and urgency to push decisions before homeowners have time to research or seek multiple opinions.
Phrases like “your insurance company may deny this if you wait” or “your roof will fail if this isn’t fixed immediately” are classic fear-based tactics. Professional roofing companies do not rely on panic. They understand the importance of allowing homeowners time to evaluate options, review documentation, and make informed decisions.
Urgency is a weapon scammers use. Patience and transparency are hallmarks of legitimate professionals.
Why Calm Decisions Protect Your Home and Your Future
After a storm, the most important step is to pause. No matter how urgent the situation feels, taking time to properly vet a contractor protects your roof, your home value, and your long-term insurance standing. Rushed decisions often lead to voided warranties, poor workmanship, and financial loss that far outweighs any short-term savings.
At Parker Brothers Roofing, we believe homeowners deserve clear information, honest assessments, and the time needed to make confident decisions. When the next storm hits, being able to tell the difference between a trusted professional and a hustler can make all the difference for your home and your peace of mind.
FAQs
-
A: Sooner rather than later, but before you sign anything, get an inspection, document the damage yourself, contact your insurer, and get multiple bids.
-
A: Not always. Coverage depends on your policy, deductible, roof condition, claim staggering, etc. Some damage may be classified as “wear and tear” or excluded if the roof is in poor condition.
-
A: Class 4 shingles are rated for high impact hail resistance. In hail‑prone Oklahoma, these can reduce damage risk and may be eligible for insurance discounts.
-
A: It can be. While not always scammy, it may signal high-pressure tactics or “upselling” you into a full replacement you may not need.
